0.07/0.12	% Problem    : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0.
0.07/0.12	% Command    : run_portfolio.sh /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p /export/starexec/sandbox2/tmp/tmp.T3HGxO519m
0.12/0.33	% Computer   : n018.cluster.edu
0.12/0.33	% Model      : x86_64 x86_64
0.12/0.33	% CPU        : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
0.12/0.33	% Memory     : 8042.1875MB
0.12/0.33	% OS         : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
0.12/0.34	% CPULimit   : 180
0.12/0.34	% DateTime   : Thu Aug 29 12:53:06 EDT 2019
0.12/0.34	% CPUTime    : 
18.05/18.58	% Running portfolio for 180 s
18.05/18.58	% File         : /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
18.05/18.58	% TempDir      : /export/starexec/sandbox2/tmp/tmp.T3HGxO519m
18.05/18.58	% Recognized as monomorphic HO.
18.05/18.58	% Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.sh for 18
18.05/18.58	% Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.2.sh for 13
18.05/18.58	% Solved by: competitive.2.sh
18.05/18.58	% done 201 iterations in 0.323s
18.05/18.58	% hashcons stats for terms: size 4096, num 2461, sum length 6300, buckets: small 0, median 3, big 7
18.05/18.58	% proof state stats: {active 185, passive 1080, simpl 0}
18.05/18.58	% SZS status Theorem for '/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p'
18.05/18.58	% SZS output start Refutation
18.05/18.58	tff(subsetTI, axiom, subsetTI <=>
18.05/18.58	  (![A,X]:
18.05/18.58	     (in(X,powerset(A)) =>
18.05/18.58	      (![Y]:
18.05/18.58	         (in(Y,powerset(A)) =>
18.05/18.58	          ((![Xx]: (in(Xx,A) => (in(Xx,X) => in(Xx,Y)))) => subset(X,Y))))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('0', plain,
18.05/18.58	    subsetTI =
18.05/18.58	    (![X2,X3]:
18.05/18.58	       (in(X3,powerset(X2)) =>
18.05/18.58	        (![X4]:
18.05/18.58	           (in(X4,powerset(X2)) =>
18.05/18.58	            ((![X5]: (in(X5,X2) => (in(X5,X3) => in(X5,X4)))) =>
18.05/18.58	             subset(X3,X4)))))),
18.05/18.58	    define([status(thm)])).
18.05/18.58	tff(complementT_lem, axiom, complementT_lem <=>
18.05/18.58	  (![A,X]: (in(X,powerset(A)) => in(setminus(A,X),powerset(A))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('1', plain,
18.05/18.58	    complementT_lem =
18.05/18.58	    (![X2,X3]: (in(X3,powerset(X2)) => in(setminus(X2,X3),powerset(X2)))),
18.05/18.58	    define([status(thm)])).
18.05/18.58	tff(setminusER, axiom, setminusER <=>
18.05/18.58	  (![A,B,Xx]: (in(Xx,setminus(A,B)) => (~in(Xx,B))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('2', plain,
18.05/18.58	    setminusER = (![X2,X3,X4]: (in(X4,setminus(X2,X3)) => (~in(X4,X3)))),
18.05/18.58	    define([status(thm)])).
18.05/18.58	tff(setminusI, axiom, setminusI <=>
18.05/18.58	  (![A,B,Xx]: (in(Xx,A) => ((~in(Xx,B)) => in(Xx,setminus(A,B)))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('3', plain,
18.05/18.58	    setminusI =
18.05/18.58	    (![X2,X3,X4]: (in(X4,X2) => ((~in(X4,X3)) => in(X4,setminus(X2,X3))))),
18.05/18.58	    define([status(thm)])).
18.05/18.58	tff(subsetE, axiom, subsetE <=>
18.05/18.58	  (![A,B,Xx]: (subset(A,B) => (in(Xx,A) => in(Xx,B))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('4', plain,
18.05/18.58	    subsetE = (![X2,X3,X4]: (subset(X2,X3) => (in(X4,X2) => in(X4,X3)))),
18.05/18.58	    define([status(thm)])).
18.05/18.58	tff(contrasubsetT2, conjecture,
18.05/18.58	  (subsetE =>
18.05/18.58	   (setminusI =>
18.05/18.58	    (setminusER =>
18.05/18.58	     (complementT_lem =>
18.05/18.58	      (subsetTI =>
18.05/18.58	       (![A,X]:
18.05/18.58	          (in(X,powerset(A)) =>
18.05/18.58	           (![Y]:
18.05/18.58	              (in(Y,powerset(A)) =>
18.05/18.58	               (subset(X,Y) => subset(setminus(A,Y),setminus(A,X))))))))))))).
18.05/18.58	tff(zf_stmt_0, conjecture,
18.05/18.58	  ((![X2,X3,X4]: (subset(X2,X3) => (in(X4,X2) => in(X4,X3)))) =>
18.05/18.58	   ((![X5,X6,X7]: (in(X7,X5) => ((~in(X7,X6)) => in(X7,setminus(X5,X6))))) =>
18.05/18.58	    ((![X8,X9,X10]: (in(X10,setminus(X8,X9)) => (~in(X10,X9)))) =>
18.05/18.58	     ((![X11,X12]:
18.05/18.58	         (in(X12,powerset(X11)) => in(setminus(X11,X12),powerset(X11)))) =>
18.05/18.58	      ((![X13,X14]:
18.05/18.58	          (in(X14,powerset(X13)) =>
18.05/18.58	           (![X15]:
18.05/18.58	              (in(X15,powerset(X13)) =>
18.05/18.58	               ((![X16]: (in(X16,X13) => (in(X16,X14) => in(X16,X15)))) =>
18.05/18.58	                subset(X14,X15)))))) =>
18.05/18.58	       (![X17,X18]:
18.05/18.58	          (in(X18,powerset(X17)) =>
18.05/18.58	           (![X19]:
18.05/18.58	              (in(X19,powerset(X17)) =>
18.05/18.58	               (subset(X18,X19) =>
18.05/18.58	                subset(setminus(X17,X19),setminus(X17,X18))))))))))))).
18.05/18.58	tff(zf_stmt_1, negated_conjecture,
18.05/18.58	  (~
18.05/18.58	    ((![X2,X3,X4]: (subset(X2,X3) => (in(X4,X2) => in(X4,X3)))) =>
18.05/18.58	     ((![X5,X6,X7]: (in(X7,X5) => ((~in(X7,X6)) => in(X7,setminus(X5,X6))))) =>
18.05/18.58	      ((![X8,X9,X10]: (in(X10,setminus(X8,X9)) => (~in(X10,X9)))) =>
18.05/18.58	       ((![X11,X12]:
18.05/18.58	           (in(X12,powerset(X11)) => in(setminus(X11,X12),powerset(X11)))) =>
18.05/18.58	        ((![X13,X14]:
18.05/18.58	            (in(X14,powerset(X13)) =>
18.05/18.58	             (![X15]:
18.05/18.58	                (in(X15,powerset(X13)) =>
18.05/18.58	                 ((![X16]: (in(X16,X13) => (in(X16,X14) => in(X16,X15)))) =>
18.05/18.58	                  subset(X14,X15)))))) =>
18.05/18.58	         (![X17,X18]:
18.05/18.58	            (in(X18,powerset(X17)) =>
18.05/18.58	             (![X19]:
18.05/18.58	                (in(X19,powerset(X17)) =>
18.05/18.58	                 (subset(X18,X19) =>
18.05/18.58	                  subset(setminus(X17,X19),setminus(X17,X18)))))))))))))).
18.05/18.58	tff('5', plain, in(sk_X19_, powerset(sk_X17_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('6', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X24, X25]:
18.05/18.58	      (in(setminus(X24, X25), powerset(X24)) | ~ in(X25, powerset(X24))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('7', plain, in(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), powerset(sk_X17_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['5', '6'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('8', plain, in(sk_X18_, powerset(sk_X17_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('9', plain, in(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), powerset(sk_X17_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['8', '6'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('10', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X21, X22, X23]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X21, powerset(X22))
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X23, X21)
18.05/18.58	       | in(sk_X16_(X21, X23, X22), X22)
18.05/18.58	       | ~ in(X23, powerset(X22))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('11', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X0]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X0, powerset(sk_X17_))
18.05/18.58	       | in(sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), X0, sk_X17_), sk_X17_)
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X0, setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['9', '10'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('12', plain,
18.05/18.58	    (subset(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))
18.05/18.58	     | in(
18.05/18.58	         sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	           sk_X17_), sk_X17_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['7', '11'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('13', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ~ subset(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('14', plain,
18.05/18.58	    in(
18.05/18.58	      sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	        sk_X17_), sk_X17_),
18.05/18.58	    inference('clc', [status(thm)], ['12', '13'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('15', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X26, X27, X28]:
18.05/18.58	      (in(X26, X27) | in(X26, setminus(X28, X27)) | ~ in(X26, X28)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('16', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X0]:
18.05/18.58	      (in(
18.05/18.58	         sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	           sk_X17_), setminus(sk_X17_, X0))
18.05/18.58	       | in(
18.05/18.58	           sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	             sk_X17_), X0)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['14', '15'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('17', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X21, X22, X23]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X21, powerset(X22))
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X23, X21)
18.05/18.58	       | ~ in(sk_X16_(X21, X23, X22), X21)
18.05/18.58	       | ~ in(X23, powerset(X22))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('18', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X0]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X0, powerset(sk_X17_))
18.05/18.58	       | ~ in(sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), X0, sk_X17_), 
18.05/18.58	             setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X0, setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['9', '17'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('19', plain,
18.05/18.58	    (in(
18.05/18.58	       sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	         sk_X17_), sk_X18_)
18.05/18.58	     | subset(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))
18.05/18.58	     | ~ in(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), powerset(sk_X17_))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['16', '18'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('20', plain,
18.05/18.58	    (~ in(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), powerset(sk_X17_))
18.05/18.58	     | in(
18.05/18.58	         sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	           sk_X17_), sk_X18_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('clc', [status(thm)], ['19', '13'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('21', plain,
18.05/18.58	    in(
18.05/18.58	      sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	        sk_X17_), sk_X18_),
18.05/18.58	    inference('clc', [status(thm)], ['20', '7'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('22', plain, subset(sk_X18_, sk_X19_),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('23', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X15, X16, X17]: (~ subset(X15, X16) | in(X17, X16) | ~ in(X17, X15)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('24', plain, ![X0]: (~ in(X0, sk_X18_) | in(X0, sk_X19_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['22', '23'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('25', plain,
18.05/18.58	    in(
18.05/18.58	      sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	        sk_X17_), sk_X19_),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['21', '24'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('26', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X21, X22, X23]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X21, powerset(X22))
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X23, X21)
18.05/18.58	       | in(sk_X16_(X21, X23, X22), X23)
18.05/18.58	       | ~ in(X23, powerset(X22))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('27', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X0]:
18.05/18.58	      (~ in(X0, powerset(sk_X17_))
18.05/18.58	       | in(sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), X0, sk_X17_), X0)
18.05/18.58	       | subset(X0, setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['9', '26'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('28', plain,
18.05/18.58	    (subset(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_))
18.05/18.58	     | in(
18.05/18.58	         sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	           sk_X17_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['7', '27'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('29', plain,
18.05/18.58	    in(
18.05/18.58	      sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	        sk_X17_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_)),
18.05/18.58	    inference('clc', [status(thm)], ['28', '13'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('30', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ![X18, X19, X20]: (~ in(X18, X19) | ~ in(X18, setminus(X20, X19))),
18.05/18.58	    inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])).
18.05/18.58	tff('31', plain,
18.05/18.58	    ~ in(
18.05/18.58	        sk_X16_(setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X18_), setminus(sk_X17_, sk_X19_), 
18.05/18.58	          sk_X17_), sk_X19_),
18.05/18.58	    inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['29', '30'])).
18.05/18.58	tff('32', plain, $false, inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['25', '31'])).
18.05/18.58	
18.05/18.58	% SZS output end Refutation
18.05/18.58	% Zipperpin 1.5 exiting
18.05/18.58	EOF